feat: drop the typed first-message hint from the Discord bridge (#741)

Owner decision. Typing the note into a brand-new non-Claude tab spent a model
turn per tab and, for a spawned worker or a scheduled run, landed with the first
real prompt. Claude keeps its hint through the system prompt, and every other CLI
is told nothing. The setting goes with the path it gated: sessionIdle, the fresh
set, isHintableSession and the session:idle wiring. sendInput loses `fromUser`,
which was only ever false for the hint, and the deps test pins that a reply is a
person's own input.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Codeman maintainer committed 2026-11-04 17:03:14 +01:00
1 parent 7c8d440928
commit 9d04a4fb02
14 files changed
+51 -189

No files matched your search

+1 -1
View File
@@ -1530,7 +1530,7 @@ One thread per tab in a private Discord channel, alerts out and replies typed ba
| Method | Path | Body | Notes |
| ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ |
| `GET` | `/api/discord` | none | Config without the token, plus `hasToken`, `tokenMasked`, `gateway` (`off` \| `connecting` \| `connected` \| `error`), `gatewayError` and `lastResult`. |
| `PUT` | `/api/discord` | `{ enabled?, token?, guildId?, parentChannelId?, allowedUserIds?, threadCreation?, onSessionDelete?, staleThreads?, pingMode?, scope?, startupHint?, typedHint? }` (strict) | `threadCreation`: `lazy` \| `onSessionStart`. `onSessionDelete`: `keep` \| `archive` \| `delete`. `pingMode`: `off` \| `critical` \| `all`. `scope`: `attention` \| `all`. An absent `token` keeps the saved one; `""` clears it. `400` for a non-numeric id or enabling without a token, guild, channel and at least one allowed user. |
| `PUT` | `/api/discord` | `{ enabled?, token?, guildId?, parentChannelId?, allowedUserIds?, threadCreation?, onSessionDelete?, staleThreads?, pingMode?, scope?, startupHint? }` (strict) | `threadCreation`: `lazy` \| `onSessionStart`. `onSessionDelete`: `keep` \| `archive` \| `delete`. `pingMode`: `off` \| `critical` \| `all`. `scope`: `attention` \| `all`. An absent `token` keeps the saved one; `""` clears it. `400` for a non-numeric id or enabling without a token, guild, channel and at least one allowed user. |
| `POST` | `/api/discord/test` | none | Posts one message to the parent channel with the saved config, even while disabled. `200` with `data.ok`; `400` if no token or channel is saved. |
| `POST` | `/api/sessions/:id/discord-notify` | `{ message, urgent?, file? }` (strict, message 1 to 1500 characters) | A CLI asks for the user: posts into that tab's thread, pinging when `urgent`. `file` is an absolute path inside the tab's working folder (real path, regular file, at most 8 MB, local sessions only) uploaded with the post; `400` otherwise. A `200` carries the delivery result: `data.ok` is `false` (with `data.error`) when Discord refused or failed the post. `409` while the bridge is disabled, `429` past 6 posts a minute per tab. The `codeman notify "message" [--urgent] [--file path]` command wraps this route. |
+1 -2
View File
@@ -97,14 +97,13 @@ In the Discord mobile app set the server to **All Messages**. Discord's own push
| `pingMode` | `off`, `critical`, `all` | `critical` | `critical` pings you for permission prompts, questions, errors and urgent posts |
| `scope` | `attention`, `all` | `attention` | `attention` skips the quiet "response complete" event. `all` sends it too |
| `startupHint` | on, off | on | Tell Claude about `codeman notify` in its system prompt at launch |
| `typedHint` | on, off | off | Also send the note once, as a first message, to brand-new non-Claude CLI tabs |
## Telling the CLIs
A CLI only posts deliberately if it knows it can. While the bridge is on:
- **Claude** (`startupHint`, on by default) is launched with `--append-system-prompt`, so nothing shows in the conversation. This reaches local tabs only: remote (ssh) and Docker launches are built outside the CLI registry, and have no `codeman` command anyway.
- **Every other CLI** is sent nothing unless you turn on `typedHint` (off by default: it costs one model turn per tab, and for a spawned worker or a scheduled run it arrives together with the first real prompt). With it on, the same text is sent once, as a message, the first time a brand-new tab becomes idle. Tabs that are restored when Codeman starts, shell tabs, and remote (ssh) and Docker tabs (which have no `codeman` command) are never sent it.
- **Every other CLI** is sent nothing: there is no silent way to tell it, and typing the note as a message would cost a model turn per tab. It can still run `codeman notify` if you tell it to.
The text explains `codeman notify "message" --urgent`. `codeman` is on the PATH of every session from the installer or an npm install (a git checkout run without the installer has no `codeman` command) and reads `CODEMAN_SESSION_ID` and `CODEMAN_API_URL`, so no other setup is needed. Without a bridge it prints that the bridge is off and exits cleanly. Tabs started before the bridge was enabled are not told; use the skill or `CLAUDE.md` for those.
+1 -1
View File
@@ -582,7 +582,7 @@ Opt-in and off by default: the server POSTs the Web Push events (permission prom
- **A second server-side outbound channel through the web-tab egress guard (§10b).** Delivery goes through `webviewFetch`, so link-local and cloud-metadata targets are refused at save time and again on the RESOLVED address at connect time; redirects are not followed (`redirect: 'manual'`) and each send is bounded by a 5 s timeout. Loopback and RFC1918 stay allowed on purpose (a self-hosted ntfy is the point), so **Send test** works as a blind reachability probe (status, refused or timed out, never a response body) for whoever may call it. Web tabs already give that caller full LAN reach with bodies, so nothing new is exposed.
- **The URL is a bearer secret** (anyone holding a Slack or Discord webhook URL can post as it). It lives in `~/.codeman/webhook.json` (0600, tmp+rename), is kept out of `settings.json` (which every logged-in user reads through `GET /api/settings`), is never returned (`GET /api/webhook` gives scheme + host only), and never appears in a log line, a delivery result or an error message.
- **Discord bridge** (`src/discord-bridge.ts`, [setup](discord-bridge.md)): the bot token lives in `~/.codeman/discord.json` (0600, tmp+rename) and is never returned, logged or put in an error. Inbound replies are typed into a session only from `allowedUserIds`, in the configured guild, inside a thread the bridge created; anything else is dropped unread. A reply becomes one printable line plus Enter, capped at 1000 characters and one per second per tab. Posts send `allowed_mentions` limited to the allowlisted ids, so agent output cannot ping a server. **Files:** an attachment is fetched only from Discord's own HTTPS hosts (no redirects followed), at most 5 per reply and 8 MB each, saved 0600 under `<tab folder>/.codeman-discord/` with the name reduced to `[A-Za-z0-9._-]`; a file a CLI sends must be a regular file whose real path (symlinks followed) lies inside its own tab's folder, which stops a file outside that folder being uploaded by mistake, and remote sessions send and receive none. A received file is untrusted content to whatever opens it. **What the checks do not stop:** the agent runs as the same OS user, so the path check prevents accidental uploads, not a determined agent that pastes a file's contents into the message. **What leaves the machine:** a permission or question alert sends the rendered screen (whatever the agent printed), and a finished turn or an error sends the CLI's whole last message, read from its transcript (up to 8 posts of 1,900 characters). `idle_prompt` is a warning, so with the default scope every Claude turn left unanswered for a minute is posted, and with **Which events** set to Everything every turn end is; treat the Discord server as holding that output. **Multi-user:** the bridge is one allowlist for the whole server, so an allowlisted Discord account can type into every user's sessions; only an admin can configure it. **Startup hint:** a fixed text (no user input) is added to Claude's system prompt, or, only when `typedHint` is on, typed once to a brand-new external CLI tab, never to a shell. The bridge only dials out (REST and the gateway WebSocket), so it needs no inbound exposure. A Discord account on the allowlist can drive agents that run shell commands: it needs 2FA.
- **Discord bridge** (`src/discord-bridge.ts`, [setup](discord-bridge.md)): the bot token lives in `~/.codeman/discord.json` (0600, tmp+rename) and is never returned, logged or put in an error. Inbound replies are typed into a session only from `allowedUserIds`, in the configured guild, inside a thread the bridge created; anything else is dropped unread. A reply becomes one printable line plus Enter, capped at 1000 characters and one per second per tab. Posts send `allowed_mentions` limited to the allowlisted ids, so agent output cannot ping a server. **Files:** an attachment is fetched only from Discord's own HTTPS hosts (no redirects followed), at most 5 per reply and 8 MB each, saved 0600 under `<tab folder>/.codeman-discord/` with the name reduced to `[A-Za-z0-9._-]`; a file a CLI sends must be a regular file whose real path (symlinks followed) lies inside its own tab's folder, which stops a file outside that folder being uploaded by mistake, and remote sessions send and receive none. A received file is untrusted content to whatever opens it. **What the checks do not stop:** the agent runs as the same OS user, so the path check prevents accidental uploads, not a determined agent that pastes a file's contents into the message. **What leaves the machine:** a permission or question alert sends the rendered screen (whatever the agent printed), and a finished turn or an error sends the CLI's whole last message, read from its transcript (up to 8 posts of 1,900 characters). `idle_prompt` is a warning, so with the default scope every Claude turn left unanswered for a minute is posted, and with **Which events** set to Everything every turn end is; treat the Discord server as holding that output. **Multi-user:** the bridge is one allowlist for the whole server, so an allowlisted Discord account can type into every user's sessions; only an admin can configure it. **Startup hint:** a fixed text (no user input) is added to Claude's system prompt; no other CLI is sent it. The bridge only dials out (REST and the gateway WebSocket), so it needs no inbound exposure. A Discord account on the allowlist can drive agents that run shell commands: it needs 2FA.
- **It carries session data to a third party.** Titles and bodies include session names, tool names and error text, all agent- or user-controlled, so Discord gets `allowed_mentions: { parse: [] }` and Slack's `& < >` are escaped: agent output cannot ping a channel. In multi-user mode all three routes are admin-only and the channel is instance-wide: it receives every user's session events, the same reach an admin's own Web Push has, which means non-admins' session details leave the box at the admin's choice.
---
+1 -3
View File
@@ -47,7 +47,6 @@ only), never in the shared settings, and never shown again once saved.
| @ ping | Never, critical events only, every post | Critical only |
| Which events | Needs attention, or everything | Needs attention |
| Tell Claude how to reach you | On or off | On |
| Also tell other CLIs, as a first message | On or off | Off |
A finished turn, and an error, is posted as the CLI's whole last message, with its formatting and questions
kept, split over several posts if it is long. A shell, and permission or question dialogs, show the last lines
@@ -69,8 +68,7 @@ permission prompt, a question, an error, or a post an agent marked urgent.
An agent only posts deliberately if it knows it can:
- **Claude** is launched with the instruction as part of its system prompt (**Tell Claude how to reach you**, on by default), so nothing shows in the chat. This reaches local tabs only (remote and Docker tabs have no `codeman` command).
- **Every other CLI** is told only if you turn on **Also tell other CLIs, as a first message** (off by default: it costs one model turn per tab, and for a spawned worker or a scheduled run it arrives with the first real prompt). Then the same text is sent once, as a message, the first time a brand-new tab goes idle.
Restored tabs, shell tabs, and remote (ssh) and Docker tabs (which have no `codeman` command) are never sent it.
- **Every other CLI** is not told. It can still run `codeman notify` if you tell it to.
Tabs that were already open when you turned the bridge on are not told. The alerts still reach
Discord for them; only the agent-initiated `codeman notify` habit is missing.